Episode 2
How Viable is Western Liberal Democracy when Transplanted Across the World?

In this episode of Democracy in Question? Shalini Randeria asks if the ideals of liberal democracy – free and fair elections, separation of powers, rule of law and respect for human rights – may be exported easily from the West to other parts of the world? This is a question especially salient when some of these very ideals are being undermined in several countries including the United States (more about this question in the first episode? Further, Prof. Randeria asks her guests, Laurence Whitehead and Yanina Welp, if Western models of democracy ought to be transplanted to other regions of the world at all?

The conversation considers the failings of modernization theory, and to what extent it was simply mistaken in assuming that there can be a unilinear, unidirectional path to ever greater freedom with the successful transplantation of western style, liberal democratic institutions everywhere. This episode features questions concerning democracy’s relationship with populism and capitalism, as well as a discussion of democratic innovations from Latin America that may be of interest to the Western world.

The podcast series Democracy in Question? is hosted by Shalini Randeria, Director of the Albert Hirschman Centre on Democracy at the Graduate Institute in Geneva, and Director of the Institute of Human Sciences in Vienna. Episode 2 features Laurence Whitehead, an Official Fellow in politics at Nuffield College, University of Oxford, and Yanina Welp, research fellow at the Albert Hirschman Centre on Democracy. Yanina and Laurence recently edited a book together titled, The Politics of Recall Elections, that analyses the variety of processes and purposes of recall, by comparing the practices and outcomes of removing elected officials before the end of their term.

This podcast series is co-produced by the Graduate Institute’s Albert Hirschman Centre on Democracy, the Institute for Human Sciences (IWM) Vienna, and the Excellence Chair, University of Bremen (Research Group: Soft Authoritarianism) in collaboration with Richard Miron and Anouk Millet (Earshot strategies).

Latest Episodes

  • Episode 5
    ‘Soft Authoritarianism’, a New Face of Electoral Democracy?

    A new kind of elected leader has emerged across the globe: one who rules with a large parliamentary majority and this with a claim to democratic legitimacy, but who uses power to hollow out democracy from the inside. So is such ‘soft authoritarianism’ that uses the law to undermine liberal principles a new face of electoral democracy? Professor John Keane(University of Sydney) helps us dissect this pervasive pattern of new despotisms and their strategies of rule.
    Read more

  • Episode 4
    Can Liberal Democracies Right the Wrongs of Racial and Gender Injustices?

    We have recently seen millions of people taking to the streets to protest social, political and environmental injustices. Even a global pandemic couldn’t stop protesters across the world from showing their support to the Black Lives Matter movement. In this episode, we’re joined by Professor Nancy Fraser (The New School) and ask: can liberal democracy provide the distributive justice citizens seem to crave?
    Read more

  • Episode 3
    Undermining Democracy by Democratic Means: how can we stop it?

    As the results of the 2020 US election are trickling in, we are taking a look at how laws - and notably electoral laws - can be used to dismantle the constitutional systems from within. In this episode, our guest Professor Kim Lane Sheppele (Princeton University) helps us understand how a new kind of elected leader is using their democratic mandates to take the whole system apart, how they are getting away with it and what we can do to stop it.
    Read more

  • Episode 2
    How Viable is Western Liberal Democracy when Transplanted Across the World?

    In this episode of Democracy in Question? Shalini Randeria asks if the ideals of liberal democracy – free and fair elections, separation of powers, rule of law and respect for human rights – may be exported easily from the West to other parts of the world? This is a question especially salient when some of these very ideals are being undermined in several countries including the United States (more about this question in the first episode? Further, Prof. Randeria asks her guests, Laurence Whitehead and Yanina Welp, if Western models of democracy ought to be transplanted to other regions of the world at all?
    Read more

  • Episode 1
    A Trumpian Blip or a Fundamental Flaw in American Democracy?

    In this episode, Shalini Randeria explores in a conversation with Timothy Snyder the reasons behind Trump’s access to power, the propensities that Trumpian politics shares with fascism, the unaddressed original sins of American democracy, as well as the future predicaments for democracy opening up in the wake of Trump.
    Read more

  • Introducing Democracy in Question

    Today, liberal democracies are under unprecedented strain from within and without. In each episode, renowned social anthropologist and IWM rector Shalini Randeria invites a leading scholar to explore the challenges and dilemmas facing democracies around the world. They investigate what needs to be done to ensure the future well-being of our democratic institutions and practices.
    Read more