Digitality and Democracy

Great hopes were placed just a few decades ago in the empowering impact of digital technology. It was expected to enable unprecedented citizen participation and strengthen monitory democracy, to use John Keane’s apt term for the continuous public control of power, by improving interconnectivity and equalizing access to information for users. Some even prophesied the dawn of a new era of direct democracy.

Alas, very soon the initial enthusiasm gave way to disillusionment. The expected empowerment failed to materialise while concern about surveillance as well concentration of power through and over big data grew by the day. Digital tools came to be seen as significantly exacerbating the ongoing crisis of democracy instead of enriching and deepening it. Three essays included in an edited volume on the current crisis of democracy published in 2019 by the IWM broach the link between the pervasiveness of digital technology and the corrosion of democratic institutions. Populist politicians and authoritarian regimes, rather than the defenders of liberal democratic values, seem to have used and benefited most from digital tools. Expectations of strengthening monitory democracy have now given way to fears of the emergence of the surveillance state with powerful digital capabilities.

Paradoxically instead of opening up new vistas of practically unlimited knowledge for interconnected users, digitality has often led to their atomisation within subtly controlled, restricted environments. Despite the possibility of access to more and better information, internet users are in fact much less exposed to a variety of different opinions than before. This  has promoted polarisation rather than the formation of informed opinion based on facts. Internet and social media have become to an alarming degree vehicles of deliberate disinformation (“fake news”) and manipulation of millions of people, including their voting preferences. In a recent essay, Timothy Snyder draws attention to a new emerging regime of digital tyranny characterised by the systematic negation of truth that not only has a devastating effect on democracy but also on the very future of humanity. Indeed, it is due to this overwhelming destructive potential of digital technology that mathematician Cathy O’Neil has termed Big Data and algorithms as “weapons of math destruction”.

Although as a rule the impact of the digital revolution on the economy is discussed independently from its implications for politics, it is hardly without consequences for democracy as also for our working lives. Reflecting on the promises and risks of automation, economic historian Robert Skidelsky calls for both a regulation of the ‘roll-out’ of the new technology and a reorientation of the economy towards ethical goals. It becomes increasingly evident that the regulation of technology is as essential for democracy to survive the digital challenge as is a refashioning of the ethical foundations of politics, economy and science. Though difficult, this is a necessary and worthwhile task.

Weekly Focus III:

Related Posts:

  • Max Schrems:
    Kämpf um deine Daten

    Max Schrems machte 2014 weltweit Schlagzeilen, als er mit einer Sammelklage gegen Facebook die kommerzielle Nutzung und Weitergabe individueller User-Daten beim Europäischen Gerichtshof anfocht. Der österreichische Jurist bekam Recht und kippte damit das Safe-Harbor-Abkommen zwischen der EU und den USA – ein wichtiger Sieg im Kampf für Datenschutz im digitalen Zeitalter. In einem Gespräch mit IWM-Rektorin Shalini …
    Read more

  • Lord Robert Skidelsky:
    The Future of Work

    In contemporary discussions about the future of artificial intelligence we often lose our heads. While economists offer bleak predictions of mass job losses and a deepening of already widespread precarity, Silicon Valley utopians insist that new technologies are bringing us ever closer together and will one day deliver us from work, disease and poverty. But …
    Read more

  • Lord Robert Skidelsky:
    Will the Human Race Become Redundant?

     What History and Economics can Tell us About the Impact of Automation on Work Ever since the advent of machinery, work has been associated with wage labour. Machinery brought promise of both higher wages and  redundancy. What do economics and history tell us about the fate of these promises? With the spread of automation …
    Read more

  • Debating Europe:
    How Much Transparency Does Democracy Need?

    Democracy is in crisis. Citizens are deeply disillusioned with political and business elites. Many believe that more transparency would restore trust in democratic institutions and corporations as only informed citizens are able to hold politicians and CEOs accountable. However, due to the endemic spread of surveillance and social media it is the citizen who has …
    Read more

  • Vienna Humanities Festival 2017:
    The Revolution Will Be Digitized

    Technology is reshaping the world around us, presenting new challenges and promising innovations. Jigsaw, the “think-do-tank” of Google, sits squarely at the intersection of technology and global security challenges—tackling issues like radicalization, online harassment, censorship, and cybercrime. Jigsaw’s Managing Director Scott Carpenter joins IWM Permanent Fellow Ivan Krastev to explain how his team is using …
    Read more

  • Europa im Diskurs:
    Bedroht die Digitalisierung die Demokratie?

    Ob über Smartphones, im Auto oder am Arbeitsplatz: Mensch und Maschine sind in einer sehr engen Beziehung – und oft wird die Maschine von künstlicher Intelligenz gesteuert. Unser Leben kann dadurch vereinfacht und verbessert werden. Künstliche Intelligenz kann aber auch Meinungen beeinflussen, Wahlen manipulieren, politische Entscheidungen lenken. Cybersecurity wird ein immer größeres Thema. Wie wirkt …
    Read more

  • Vienna Humanities Festival 2019:
    Social Networks or Social Nightmares?

    A decade ago social networks, big data and artificial intelligence were welcomed for their promise of progress and democratization of access. Today, the focus has shifted to their dark side as a threat to our privacy, a danger to democracy and as a new form of surveillance. Three of the world’s leading activists of the …
    Read more

  • Debating Europe:
    The Dangers of Digital Democracy

    All over the world, elections are manipulated by fake news, public opinion is radicalized via social media and electronic voting processes are subject to hacker attacks. The Internet was once seen as an opportunity for more democracy, but today concerns about the future of free elections prevail. Eric Frey, editor of Der Standard, will speak …
    Read more

  • Automatisierung der Arbeit: Segen oder Fluch?

    “Die Politik sollte ständig das Ziel vor Augen haben, den „notwendigen“ Arbeitsaufwand zu reduzieren. Dies war das Hauptversprechen der Mechanisierung, nicht ein unbegrenztes Konsumwachstum. (…) Wir haben das Wachstum des Bruttoinlandprodukts zum Selbstzweck gemacht – ein Vergehen an den Göttern, aber auch an dem Planeten, dessen Treuhänder wir sind. Die Politik kann wenig tun, um …
    Read more

  • Und wie elektrische Schafe träumen wir: Humanität, Sexualität, Digitalität

    So wie ein lädierter Apfel Fliegen anlockt, zieht menschlicher Leichtsinn Algorithmen an. Digitale Wesen nutzen unsere Selbstüberschätzung aus, bestärken unsere falschen Überzeugungen, instrumentalisieren unsere sexuellen Ängste, reduzieren uns auf isolierte Tiere und veranlassen uns schließlich dazu, die Reste unserer Intelligenz dazu zu verwenden, ihnen ein Alibi für ihre Taten zu geben.” Timothy Snyder Timothy Snyder diskutiert …
    Read more

  • Wenn Demokratien demokratisch untergehen

    Demokratie ist die Regierungsform unserer Zeit. Dennoch erodiert ihre Legitimität gleichsam von innen heraus. Wie vollzieht sich dieser Prozess und welche Handlungsmöglichkeiten gibt es, dem demokratischen Untergang der Demokratie entgegenzuwirken? Die weltweite Verbreitung und Beliebtheit der Demokratie gehen mit ihrer Krise einher. Im historischen Moment ihrer größten Ausdehnung scheint – aus dem Innern der Demokratie …
    Read more

Related Links: