Week I: Corona and Resurgence of Communitarian Ideas

Weekly Focus curated by Ludger Hagedorn

Although liberal democracies will hopefully prove capable of mastering the Corona pandemic, this does not mean that everything will, or should, remain unchanged. Perhaps this crisis entails a clear message for our highly individualized societies, namely that the mere pursuit of one’s self-interest is not enough.

Will Western liberal societies be able to fight against the Corona pandemic with the same rigor and severity as China’s authoritarian regime? This was a nagging concern of defenders of liberalism as the new epicenter of the pandemic shifted to Europe and the United States in mid-March. Would the measures they adopt to stem its spread be as successful as the Chinese ones? Would liberal democracies have the political will to impose restrictions and be able to exercise the necessary control of their citizens to ensure obedience? After three weeks of social distancing, an almost complete standstill of the economy as well as of public life, and a significant decline in the numbers of new infections in most EU countries, we may conclude that liberal societies accepted the challenge and can cope with the crisis.
[Read more]

Charles Taylor, who has been a Non-Resident Permanent Fellow of IWM for many years, published one of his groundbreaking articles on the topic in the Institute’s journal Transit. Published in winter 1992/93 this now classic text was aptly entitled “Wieviel Gemeinschaft braucht die Demokratie?” (How much community is needed for democracy?). It was republished (also in English) in 2017 by IWM’s partner journal Eurozine. This week’s thematic focus provides links to the English as well as to the German version.

Michael Sandel, another key thinkers on communitarianism and long-time associate of the IWM,  gave a lecture in memory of the IWM’s founding rector Krzysztof Michalski in 2013, which reflects on the irreplaceable role that solidarity plays in our societies. He also took part in a panel discussion of the series Europa im Diskurs – Debating Europe at the Burgtheater on April 7, 2013. Together with Elsa Fornero, Ira Katznelson, Michael Sandel and Andreas Treichl he discussed how to escape the crises and to promote new models of solidarity and good life. Read the summary in IWMpost 112 or watch the video.

Das Thema Pflege und Sorgearbeit ist durch die Corona-Krise in den Fokus der Öffentlichkeit geraten. Dass das Thema damals wie heute ein hochpolitisches ist, hat Erna Appelt am Beispiel des österreichischen Care-Regimes bereits in einem IWMpost-Artikel aus dem Jahr 2014 thematisiert. Ihr Beitrag zeigt, dass die Reformen der letzten Jahrzehnte zwar zu einer gewissen Anerkennung von Pflegeleistungen geführt haben, neoliberale Modernisierungsmaßnahmen aber gleichzeitig bestehende Hierarchien verfestigt und neue Ungleichheiten geschaffen haben.
[Read more]

Humanity and Catastrophe – In this conversation, between Philippe Sands and Serhii Plokhii, which was part of the conference  Between Kyiv and Vienna: Histories of People, Ideas, and Objects in Circulation and Motion at the IWM in December 2019, the two authors reflect on the systemic and personal facets of large-scale disaster, the relationship between silence and memory, and lessons for humanity’s future.
[Read more]

How is capitalism best conceptualized  – as an economic system, a form of ethical life, or an institutional order? In her Patočka Memorial Lecture of the year 2013, Nancy Fraser, Professor of Philosophy and Politics at the New School for Social Research in New York, addressed the current sense of crisis – in economy, ecology, politics, and society – which prompted many critical theorists to revisit the problem of capitalism. In her lecture, Nancy Fraser saluted this return to core issues of social theory after a period of neglect.
[Read more]

Related Videos:




Weekly Focus I: Corona and Resurgence of Communitarian Ideas

curated by Ludger Hagedorn

Related Posts:

  • Nancy Fraser:
    Crisis, Critique, Capitalism – A Framework for the 21st Century

    How is capitalism best conceptualized  – as an economic system, a form of ethical life, or an institutional order? In her Patočka Memorial Lecture of the year 2013, Nancy Fraser, Professor of Philosophy and Politics at the New School for Social Research in New York, addressed the current sense of crisis – in economy, ecology, …
    Read more

  • Debating Europe:
    Inequality and Solidarity

    With: Elsa Fornero Italian Minister for Labour and Social Affairs, as well as for Equal Opportunities Ira Katznelson Professor of Political Science and History, Columbia University; President, Social Science Research Council Michael Sandel Professor of Government, Harvard University Andreas Treichl CEO, Erste Group, Vienna Moderator: Alfred Gusenbauer former Chancellor of Austria Print

  • Serhii Plokhii, Philippe Sands:
    Humanity and Catastrophe

    Serhii Plokhii is the Mykhailo Hrushevsky Professor of Ukrainian History and the director of the Ukrainian Research Institute at Harvard University. His book, Chernobyl: History of a Tragedy received the 2018 Baillie Gifford Prize for Non-Fiction, and the 2019 Pushkin House Prize. His latest book is Forgotten Bastards of the Eastern Front: An Untold Story of …
    Read more

  • Michael Sandel:
    Lecture on Solidarity

     Michael Sandel is Anne T. and Robert M. Bass Professor of Government at Harvard University, where he teaches political philosophy. His writings—on justice, ethics, democracy, and markets—have been translated into 28 languages. An IWM Non-Resident Permanent Fellow, Sandel is a member of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, has been a visiting professor at the …
    Read more

  • Charles Taylor:
    Wieviel Gemeinschaft braucht die Demokratie?

    I Im Folgenden möchte ich über die Voraussetzungen der Demokratie am Ende des 20. Jahrhunderts nachdenken. Gleichzeitig möchte ich im Zuge dieser Überlegungen danach fragen, was wir heute unter dem Begriff “Demokratie” verstehen. Zuvor aber einige Bemerkungen über die zentrale Bedeutung der Demokratie für unsere Zeit. Die Demokratie ist zu einer Norm geworden, der sich …
    Read more

  • Charles Taylor:
    Some Conditions of a Viable Democracy

    I I would like to open a discussion on the conditions of a viable democracy in our late twentieth century. And, through this discussion, raise the issue at the same time of exactly what we are looking for under the word ‘democracy’. But as a sort of introduction, I want to remark on the centrality …
    Read more