Populating No Man’s Land: Economic Concepts of Ownership under Communism

This edited volume opening the new series Revisiting Communism: Collectivist Economic Thought in Historical Perspective focuses on the concepts of ownership, the cornerstone of political economy in Soviet-type societies. The authors’ main objective is to contribute to the still unwritten chapter on collectivism in the history books of modern economic thought. They trace the lengthy evolution of economic ideas of property reform under communism leading from the doctrine of blanket nationalization to projects of moderate privatization in eight countries of Eastern Europe and China.

The comparative analysis sheds light upon the tireless attempts of reform-minded economists in communist countries to populate the no man’s land of “social property” with quasi-private economic actors such as bodies of workers’ self-management and managers of state-owned companies. For a long time, these were expected to crowd out the communist nomenklatura from its actual ownership position without challenging the primacy of collective property rights. The fact that even the most radical reformers came to the conclusion that such surrogate owners would not be able to break the power of the ruling elite only on the eve of the 1989 revolutions demonstrates the immense strength of collectivist ideas. The authors coin the term “trap of collectivism” to warn those demanding nationalization or other forms of non-private ownership today: it is rather easy, even with the best intentions, to walk into this trap but it may take long decades to break out from it.

Edited by János Matyas Kovács – Contributions by János Matyas Kovács; Oleg Ananyin; Roumen Avramov; Fan Shitao; Julius Horváth; Denis Melnik; Jože Mencinger; Gabriel Mursa; Vlad Pașca; Franz Rudolph; Vítězslav Sommer; Maciej Tymiński and Hans-Jürgen Wagener

 

Publication of the Project Between Bukharin and Balcerowicz: A Comparative History of Economic Thought under Communism. Further informations: www.triple-b-project.net

 

Recent Publications

  • The Road to Unfreedom. Russia, Europe, America

    With the end of the Cold War, the victory of liberal democracy seemed final. Observers declared the end of history, confident in a peaceful, globalized future. This faith was misplaced. Authoritarianism returned to Russia, as Putin found fascist ideas that could be used to justify rule by the wealthy. In the 2010s, it has spread …
    Read more

  • Tomaten. Die wahre Identität unseres Frischgemüses. Eine Reportage

    Mehr als sieben Jahre lang verfolgte die Journalistin Annemieke Hendriks den Lebensweg der Tomate vom Samen bis zum Supermarkt. Dabei reiste sie kreuz und quer durch Europa und geriet mitten hinein in die bizarre Welt des globalisierten Nahrungsmittelmarkts. Im Gespräch mit Züchtern, Lobbyisten, Umweltschützern und anderen Experten stellte sie Fragen, die jeden von uns angehen: …
    Read more

  • The Ukrainian Night. An Intimate History of Revolution

    A vivid and intimate account of the Ukrainian Revolution, the rare moment when the political became the existential What is worth dying for? While the world watched the uprising on the Maidan as an episode in geopolitics, those in Ukraine during the extraordinary winter of 2013–14 lived the revolution as an existential transformation: the blurring …
    Read more